Univ Michigan Universidade Federal de São Carlos (UFSCar) Hebrew Univ Jerusalem Pfizer Worldwide Res & Dev MRC Univ Toronto Linkoping Univ Univ Palermo Katholieke Univ Leuven NYU Korea Inst Sci & Technol Univ Paris Diderot York Univ Osaka Univ Univ Jordan Max Planck Inst Infect Biol INSERM Inst Pasteur VAAAHS Univ Oxford Univ Brescia Scripps Res Inst Cleveland Clin IPN Univ Penn NCI Ohio State Univ Univ Toulouse 3 Iowa State Univ City Hope Natl Med Ctr Griffith Univ Niigata Univ Univ Valencia Italian Natl Inst Hlth Univ Florida Juntendo Univ Norwegian Inst Publ Hlth Kyoto Univ Univ So Calif Univ Cincinnati Univ Nice Sophia Antipolis Kogakuin Univ Univ Massachusetts Univ N Carolina Pembroke Chinese Peoples Liberat Army Gen Hosp Univ Strasbourg Univ Arkansas Med Sci Univ Urbino Carlo Bo Telethon Inst Genet & Med TIGEM Univ Naples Federico II Baylor Coll Med Univ Toledo Univ Leicester Semmelweis Univ Univ Texas MD Anderson Canc Ctr Catholic Univ Louvain Natl Univ Singapore Univ Paris 11 INRA Univ Auvergne SUNY Albany Johannes Gutenberg Univ Mainz Goethe Univ Frankfurt Univ Rouen Univ Sydney Merck Mfg Div Magna Graecia Univ Catanzaro Univ Montpellier I Univ Roma Tor Vergata Univ Montpellier 2 Comenius Univ Western Univ Hlth Sci CNRS Indiana Univ Emory Univ Univ Padua Univ Chicago Univ Zurich Universidade Federal de São Paulo (UNIFESP) Univ Maryland CSIC Univ Franche Comte Swedish Univ Agr Sci Heidelberg Univ Univ Udine Univ Oslo Oslo Univ Hosp UNC Sch Med Univ Wisconsin CHU Nice Equipe Labellisee Assoc Rech Canc ARC Virginia Commonwealth Univ Univ Rochester Genentech Inc Hosp Sick Children Ottawa Hosp Univ N Carolina Univ Tubingen DZNE Med Univ Vienna Univ Geneva Universidade de São Paulo (USP) Inst Clin & Expt Med Albert Einstein Coll Med Vanderbilt Univ Rutgers State Univ Thomas Jefferson Univ Univ Autonoma Madrid Univ Bordeaux Segalen Univ London EBRI Rita Levi Montalcini Fdn Cent S Univ Univ Idaho Univ E Anglia Univ Coimbra Univ Texas Hlth Sci Ctr San Antonio Case Western Reserve Univ Lund Univ Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ) Univ Modena & Reggio Emilia Univ Groningen Univ Messina Univ Vita Salute San Raffaele Ist Sci San Raffaele Univ Autonoma Barcelona Univ Piemonte Orientale Univ Med Ctr Utrecht IRCCS Santa Lucia Fdn NIAID Chonbuk Univ Kaohsiung Med Univ Hosp CALTECH Univ Strathclyde Univ Hong Kong Natl Taiwan Univ Acad Sinica Shanghai Jiao Tong Univ Chinese Acad Sci Nankai Univ S China Normal Univ Zhejiang Univ Fourth Mil Med Univ Tsinghua Univ Peking Univ Mackay Mem Hosp Purdue Univ Univ Louisville Chinese Univ Hong Kong Penn State Univ Mem Sloan Kettering Canc Ctr Yonsei Univ Bond Univ Univ Tsukuba Natl Yang Ming Univ Kyung Hee Univ Harvard Univ Sungkyunkwan Univ Ajou Univ Inst Gustave Roussy Univ Tartu Univ Pittsburgh Natl Hlth Res Inst Natl Def Med Ctr Korea Univ IRCCS San Raffaele Univ Liverpool Safar Ctr Resuscitat Res Univ Lausanne Georgetown Univ Univ Paris S Princeton Univ Univ Nacl Cuyo Univ Pavia NIA Johns Hopkins Univ Pontificia Univ Catolica Chile Univ Turin Univ Calif Los Angeles Univ Oviedo Univ Valparaiso Univ Aberdeen Keck Grad Inst Appl Sci Univ Seville Univ Johannesburg Univ Iowa Santa Lucia Fdn Univ Campus Biomed Univ Cape Town Inst Canc Res Royal Marsden Hosp Univ Texas Houston Univ Utrecht Karolinska Inst Univ Pisa Univ Calif San Francisco Tufts Univ Univ Melbourne Lab Nazl Consorzio Interuniv Freiburg Inst Adv Studies FRIAS SA Pathol Univ Adelaide Univ New Mexico Louisiana State Univ Monash Univ Univ dAnnunzio Fdn Columbia Univ EMMA CNR Univ Chile Univ Alcala de Henares Sanford Burnham Med Res Inst Frankfurt Inst Mol Life Sci Univ Calif Davis Univ Kansas Washington Univ Univ Bordeaux Georgia Hlth Sci Univ Eli Lilly & Co Bogomoletz Inst Physiol Ecole Normale Super Lyon Huazhong Univ Techol & Sci Univ Lausanne Hosp Univ Paris 06 Univ Colorado Denver Univ Calif Irvine Univ Barcelona Univ Cologne Penn State Coll Med Weizmann Inst Sci Univ Milan Buck Inst Res Aging Univ Stellenbosch Technion Israel Inst Technol Latvian Biomed Res & Study Ctr Univ Helsinki George Mason Univ Univ Med & Dent New Jersey Fudan Univ Guangzhou Univ Chinese Med Kings Coll London Danish Canc Soc Univ Calif San Diego Univ Lyon 1 Univ Lyon Univ Georgia SUNY Buffalo Univ Debrecen San Diego State Univ CUNY IRCCS L Spallanzani NHLBI Rockefeller Univ Univ Colorado McGill Univ IRCCS Neuromed Univ Heidelberg Hosp Univ Nebraska Univ Copenhagen Univ Extremadura Kyushu Univ Jichi Med Univ Tohoku Univ Hannover Med Sch Univ Louvain Warsaw Univ Life Sci Indian Inst Technol Univ Dundee UT SW Med Ctr Boston Univ Univ Illinois Univ Aix Marseille 2 Univ Kentucky UCL Univ Ottawa Univ Manitoba Ist Super Sanita Democritus Univ Thrace Univ Gen Hosp Alexandroupolis Univ Lancaster Med Univ Warsaw New York Med Coll Ege Univ Univ Buenos Aires CSIC UR CAR Univ Nottingham Uniformed Serv Univ Hlth Sci BC Canc Agcy Sabanci Univ Agr Inst Slovenia Montana State Univ Life Technol Univ Occupat & Environm Hlth Trinity Coll Dublin Tokyo Metropolitan Inst Med Sci VA Boston Healthcare Syst Natl Cerebral & Cardiovasc Ctr Gifu Univ Univ S Florida Univ Texas SW Med Ctr Dallas Duke Univ CRCHUM Univ Glasgow DKFZ ZMBH Alliance Univ Bonn Sun Yat Sen Univ Univ Med Ctr Groningen LEO Pharma AS Providence Portland Med Ctr Sichuan Univ Mayo Clin Mayo Canc Ctr Univ Freiburg Univ Hosp Freiburg Seoul Natl Univ Chang Gung Mem Hosp Univ Edinburgh Chungnam Natl Univ Univ Washington Univ Durham Univ Ulsan Asan Med Ctr Tokyo Womens Med Univ Asahi Univ Hong Kong Univ Sci & Technol Nagoya Univ Yale Univ Keio Univ Univ Turku Univ Texas Med Branch Med Coll Wisconsin Publ Res Ctr Hlth CRP Sante Chungbuk Natl Univ Harbin Med Univ Univ Salamanca Korea Adv Inst Sci & Technol Univ Tromso Univ Pretoria Eotvos Lorand Univ CHUV Univ Lausanne Univ Eastern Finland Kuopio Univ Hosp Natl Ctr Neurol & Psychiat NCNP Natl Inst Basic Biol Natl Canc Ctr Singapore St Jude Childrens Res Hosp Chang Gung Univ Univ Minnesota Fraunhofer Grp Extracorporeal Immune Modulat EXIM Wayne State Univ Menoufiya Univ Hokkaido Univ Gyeongsang Natl Univ Daegu Gyeongbuk Inst Sci & Technol Wonkwang Univ Hallym Univ Univ Maryland Baltimore Cty Beatson Inst Canc Res Brown Univ Rhode Isl Hosp Merck KGaA Univ Tokyo Nagasaki Univ Univ Munich Univ Arizona Univ Hosp Ctr Invest Principe Univ Gottingen Natl Fisheries Res & Dev Inst NFRDI Huazhong Univ Sci & Technol Newcastle Univ Hiroshima Univ Univ Vienna Univ Paris 05 Babraham Inst Cincinnati Childrens Hosp Res Fdn Polish Acad Sci Commonwealth Med Coll Rady Childrens Hosp Univ Lille Nord France Univ Laval Univ Bristol Canc Res UK London Res Inst Univ Incheon Samsung Med Ctr Catholic Univ Korea Univ Rennes 1 Univ Arkansas Natl Cheng Kung Univ Dartmouth Med Sch Univ Santiago Compostela Med Univ S Carolina Rush Univ Cent Hosp Yongzhou City Inst Plant Physiol & Ecol Hanshan Normal Univ Univ Texas Hlth Sci Ctr Houston Univ S Dakota Med Univ Lodz Konkuk Univ Eunice Kennedy Shriver Natl Inst Child Hlth & Dev Univ Manchester Soochow Univ Cent China Normal Univ Texas A&M Hlth Sci Ctr SUNY Stony Brook NCI Frederick Stanford Univ Thomas Jefferson Univ & Hosp Van Andel Res Inst Graz Univ NHGRI San Raffaele Sulmona Inst Univ Sci & Technol China CAESAR Res Ctr DZNE German Ctr Neurodegenerat Dis Nanjing Agr Univ Feinstein Inst Med Res Univ Cambridge Agr Biotechnol Res Inst Iran Fdn Res & Technol Hellas Univ Crete Univ Antwerp Vall dHebron Res Inst CIBERNED NIH Osaka Prefecture Univ Univ Nice Malaghan Inst Med Res Natl Univ Ireland Univ Coll Cork Dalhousie Univ Univ Amsterdam Hosp Ramon & Cajal Girona Biomed Res Inst IDIBGi Fiocruz MS Tropenmed Grundlagenforsch Second Mil Med Univ Shandong Univ Univ Namur FUNDP Max Delbruck Ctr Mol Med Univ Siena Tokyo Med & Dent Univ Hosp Univ Vall dHebron Int Univ Hlth & Welf Plymouth Marine Lab Univ Costa Rica Saitama Univ Univ London Imperial Coll Sci Technol & Med Brigham & Womens Hosp Novartis Inst Biomed Res Wistar Inst Anat & Biol Univ Roma La Sapienza Tokai Univ Kyoto Sangyo Univ Tokyo Inst Technol NINDS Canc Res UK Radboud Univ Nijmegen New York Blood Ctr So Illinois Univ Natl Ctr Neurol & Psychiat Univ Split Natl Inst Infect Dis RIKEN Jikei Univ Ecole Polytech Fed Lausanne Univ Hawaii Univ Athens Santo Tomas Univ Childrens Hosp Pittsburgh Univ Calabria Univ Texas San Antonio Duke NUS Grad Med Sch ETH Vrije Univ Amsterdam Tel Aviv Univ Northwestern Univ Inst Claudius Regaud IRO Cornell Univ Chinese Acad Med Sci Peking Union Med Coll NIAMSD Univ British Columbia JWG Univ US FDA EMD Serono Res Inst Inc Univ S Carolina Univ Waterloo Univ Wyoming Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG) Cincinnati Childrens Hosp Ctr Invest Biol CSIC & Ciber Enfermedades Raras Univ Silesia UPMC Maastricht Univ Univ Med Ctr Eppendorf Ben Gurion Univ Negev Charles Univ Prague MIT Meikai Univ UCL Canc Inst Univ Pablo Olavide Univ Castilla La Mancha Dulbecco Telethon Inst Venetian Inst Mol Med Jawaharlal Nehru Univ Vilnius State Univ Gunma Univ Univ Zurich Hosp Univ Ulm Klinikum Univ Erlangen Nurnberg Med Coll Georgia Univ Nat Resources & Life Sci Vienna BOKU Rikshosp Radiumhosp HF Drexel Univ Korea Basic Sci Inst Kagoshima Univ Univ Alabama Birmingham Birmingham VAMC Salk Inst Biol Studies Natl Agr & Food Res Org NARO Natl Chung Hsing Univ Taipei Med Univ Natl Acad Sci Ukraine Univ Rzeszow Royal N Shore Hosp Nuffield Dept Med Univ Bern Consorzio Mario Negri Sud IRCCS Saverio Bellis Hong Kong Polytech Univ Inst Chem Technol Moscow MV Lomonosov State Univ Mahidol Univ Spanish Canc Res Ctr Hebei Med Univ Charite Indian Inst Sci Educ & Res Acad Athens Natl Canc Inst Brazil Univ Dusseldorf Wuhan Univ Univ Ryukyus Univ York Univ Texas Med Sch Houston Yokohama City Univ Univ Exeter Univ Birmingham VA Med Ctr Karolinska Univ Hosp Huddinge Univ Insubria Okayama Univ Univ Belgrade Univ Hosp Bern Jozef Stefan Inst Francis Marion Univ Oregon Hlth & Sci Univ IRCCS Casa Sollievo Sofferenza Vrije Univ Brussel Univ Ghent Katholieke Univ Leuven Hosp Hosp Clin Barcelona Univ Complutense Autonomous Univ Barcelona UAB Catalan Inst Res & Adv Studies ICREA Fac Med Toulouse IRCSS Santa Lucia Fdn Russian Acad Sci Cardiff Univ Texas A&M Inst Biosci & Technol Cleveland Clin Fdn N Shore Univ Hosp Natl Tsing Hua Univ Univ Utah House Ear Res Inst Univ Sheffield Res Ctr Julich Fujian Univ Tradit Chinese Med Xi An Jiao Tong Univ Univ Southampton Univ Oklahoma Henan Univ Technol Nagahama Inst Biosci & Technol Natl Res Inst Fisheries Sci Huazhong Agr Univ OIST Grad Univ Weis Ctr Res Indiana Univ Sch Med Univ Shizuoka AgroParisTech Chosun Univ Mt Sinai Sch Med Univ Hlth Network Ist Nazl Tumori Univ Virginia Natl Inst Biol Sci Leiden Univ Univ Newcastle Univ Calif Berkeley Univ Gothenburg CIBERDEM Max Planck Inst Psychiat VA Pittsburgh Healthcare Syst
Abstract
In 2008 we published the first set of guidelines for standardizing research in autophagy. Since then, research on this topic has continued to accelerate, and many new scientists have entered the field. Our knowledge base and relevant new technologies have also been expanding. Accordingly, it is important to update these guidelines for monitoring autophagy in different organisms. Various reviews have described the range of assays that have been used for this purpose. Nevertheless, there continues to be confusion regarding acceptable methods to measure autophagy, especially in multicellular eukaryotes. A key point that needs to be emphasized is that there is a difference between measurements that monitor the numbers or volume of autophagic elements (e.g., autophagosomes or autolysosomes) at any stage of the autophagic process vs. those that measure flux through the autophagy pathway (i.e., the complete process); thus, a block in macroautophagy that results in autophagosome accumulation needs to be differentiated from stimuli that result in increased autophagic activity, defined as increased autophagy induction coupled with increased delivery to, and degradation within, lysosomes (in most higher eukaryotes and some protists such as Dictyostelium) or the vacuole (in plants and fungi). in other words, it is especially important that investigators new to the field understand that the appearance of more autophagosomes does not necessarily equate with more autophagy. in fact, in many cases, autophagosomes accumulate because of a block in trafficking to lysosomes without a concomitant change in autophagosome biogenesis, whereas an increase in autolysosomes may reflect a reduction in degradative activity. Here, we present a set of guidelines for the selection and interpretation of methods for use by investigators who aim to examine macroautophagy and related processes, as well as for reviewers who need to provide realistic and reasonable critiques of papers that are focused on these processes. These guidelines are not meant to be a formulaic set of rules, because the appropriate assays depend in part on the question being asked and the system being used. in addition, we emphasize that no individual assay is guaranteed to be the most appropriate one in every situation, and we strongly recommend the use of multiple assays to monitor autophagy. in these guidelines, we consider these various methods of assessing autophagy and what information can, or cannot, be obtained from them. Finally, by discussing the merits and limits of particular autophagy assays, we hope to encourage technical innovation in the field.